Knowledge advantage can save lives, win wars and avert disaster. At the Central Intelligence Agency, basic artificial intelligence 91裸聊视频� machine learning and algorithms 91裸聊视频� has long served that mission. Now, generative AI is joining the effort.
CIA Director William Burns says AI tech will augment humans, not replace them. The agency91裸聊视频檚 first chief technology officer, Nand Mulchandani, is marshaling the tools. There91裸聊视频檚 considerable urgency: Adversaries are already spreading AI-generated deepfakes aimed at undermining U.S. interests.
A former Silicon Valley CEO who helmed successful startups, Mulchandani was named to the job in 2022 after a stint at the Pentagon91裸聊视频檚 Joint Artificial Intelligence Center.
Among agency projects: A ChatGPT-like generative AI application that draws on open-source data (meaning unclassified, public or commercially available). Thousands of analysts across the 18-agency U.S. intelligence community use it. Other CIA projects that use large-language models are, unsurprisingly, secret.
This Associated Press interview with Mulchandani has been edited for length and clarity.
Q: You recently said generative AI should be treated like a 91裸聊视频渃razy, drunk friend.91裸聊视频� Can you elaborate?
A: When these generative AI systems 91裸聊视频渉allucinate,91裸聊视频� they can sometimes behave like your drunk friend at a bar who can say something that pushes you outside your normal conceptual boundary and sparks out-of-the box thinking. Remember that these AI-based systems are probabilistic in nature, so they are not precise (They are prone to fabrication). So for creative tasks like art, poetry, and painting these systems are excellent. But I wouldn91裸聊视频檛 yet use these systems for doing precise math or designing an airplane or skyscraper - in those activities 91裸聊视频渃lose enough91裸聊视频� doesn91裸聊视频檛 work. They can also be biased and narrowly focused, which I call the 91裸聊视频渞abbit hole91裸聊视频� problem.
Q: The only current use of a large-language model at enterprise scale I91裸聊视频檓 aware of at CIA is the open-source AI, called Osiris, that it created for the entire intelligence community. Is that correct?
A: That91裸聊视频檚 the only one we have disclosed publicly. It91裸聊视频檚 been an absolute home run for us. We should broaden the discussion beyond just LLMs though 91裸聊视频� as an example, we process huge amounts of foreign language content in multiple media types including video, and use other AI algorithms and tools to process that.
Q: The Special Competitive Studies Project, a high-powered advisory group focused on AI in national security, is out with a report saying U.S. intelligence services must rapidly integrate generative AI 91裸聊视频� given its disruptive potential. It sets a two-year timeline for getting beyond experimentation and limited pilot projects and 91裸聊视频渄eploying Gen AI tools at scale.91裸聊视频� Do you agree?
A: CIA is all in 100% on utilizing these technologies and scaling them. We are taking this as seriously as we91裸聊视频檙e taking probably any technology issue. We think we91裸聊视频檝e beaten the initial timeline by a big margin, as we91裸聊视频檙e already using Gen AI tools in production. The deeper answer is that we91裸聊视频檙e on the early side of a huge number of additional changes, and a large part of the work is to integrate the technology more widely into our applications and systems. These are early days.
Q: Can you name your large-language model partners?
A: I91裸聊视频檓 not sure naming the vendors is interesting right now. There is an explosion of LLMs available on the market now. As a smart customer, we are not tying our boat to a specific set of LLMs or a specific set of vendors. We are evaluating and using practically all the high-runner LLMs out there, both commercial-grade and open source. We are not viewing the LLM market as a singular one where a single lab is better than the others. As you91裸聊视频檙e noting in the market, models are leapfrogging one another with each new release.
Q: What are the most important use cases at CIA for large-language models?
A: Primary is summarization. It91裸聊视频檚 impossible for an open-source analyst at CIA to digest the firehouse of media and other information we collect every day. So this has been a game-changer for insights into sentiment and global trends. Analysts then dig into specifics. They must be able 91裸聊视频� with full certainty 91裸聊视频� to annotate and explain data they cite and how they reach conclusions. Our tradecraft has not changed. The additional pieces give analysts much broader perspective 91裸聊视频� both the classified and open-source pieces we gather.
Q: What are the biggest challenges of adapting generative AI at the agency?
A: There isn91裸聊视频檛 a lot of cultural resistance internally. Our employees deal with AI on a daily basis competitively. Obviously, the whole world is on fire with these new technologies and the amazing productivity gains. The trick is grappling with constraints we have on information compartmentalization and how systems are built. In many cases, the separation of data is not for security but legal reasons. How do we efficiently connect systems to get the benefits of AI while keeping all that intact? Some really interesting technologies are emerging to help us think this through 91裸聊视频� and combine data in ways that maintain encryption and privacy controls.
Q: Generative AI is currently about as sophisticated as an elementary school student. Intelligence work, by contrast, is for grown-ups. It91裸聊视频檚 all about trying to pierce an adversary91裸聊视频檚 deception. How does Gen AI fit into that work?
A: First, let91裸聊视频檚 emphasize that the human analyst has primacy. We have the world91裸聊视频檚 leading experts in their domains. And in many cases of incoming information, a huge amount of human judgment is involved to weigh its importance and significance 91裸聊视频� including of the individuals who may be providing it. We don91裸聊视频檛 have machines replicate any of that. And we91裸聊视频檙e not looking for computers to do the jobs of domain experts.
What we are looking at is the co-pilot model. We think Gen AI can have a huge impact in brainstorming, coming up with new ideas. And in boosting productivity 91裸聊视频� and insight. We have to be very deterministic about how we do it because, wielded properly, these algorithms are a force for good. But wielded incorrectly, they can really hurt you.
READ ALSO:
Frank Bajak, The Associated Press
