91Ƶ

Skip to content

B.C.91Ƶs deal with social media giants 91Ƶprobably91Ƶ represents 91Ƶbest outcome91Ƶ: expert

Brandon Laur, CEO of The White Hatter, acknowledges problems with agreement91Ƶs impact on local news
web1_240328-rda-social-media-lawsuit-_1
Digital literacy and Internet safety education specialist Brandon Laur, CEO of The White Hatter says B.C.91Ƶs agreement with four big social media around preventing online harm and sharing information about wildfires 91Ƶprobably91Ƶ represents the 91Ƶbest outcome.91Ƶ But he also acknowledges problems with the future role of social media companies in sharing information about wildfires, given that Meta, the parent company of Facebook, continues to block Canadian news. (AP Photo/Paula Ulichney)

A digital expert says B.C.91Ƶs recent agreement with Meta and other digital companies around protecting youth online 91Ƶprobably91Ƶ represents the 91Ƶbest outcome.91Ƶ But parts of the political opposition see the agreement as a 91Ƶbackroom deal91Ƶ at the expense of local news.

Brandon Laur, CEO of The White Hatter, a digital literacy and internet safety education specialist company, said last week91Ƶs agreement with the digital media companies to speed up the removal of 91Ƶnon-consensual intimate images91Ƶ 91Ƶ so-called 91Ƶrevenge porn91Ƶ 91Ƶ allows government to see results faster.

91ƵWorking together is probably better than 91ƵI am going to sue,91Ƶ91Ƶ he said. 91ƵHow long did it take us to see changes with tobacco and now with pharmaceutical companies? That has taken years to deal with through the courts.91Ƶ

The agreement with X, formerly known as Twitter, Google, TikTok, Snap and Meta, the parent company of Facebook, emerged out of B.C.91Ƶs new online action table. The action table itself emerged after the B.C. NDP had placed Bill 12 91Ƶ the Public Health Accountability and Cost Recovery Act 91Ƶ on hold. The bill 91Ƶ which died last week with the end of the legislative session 91Ƶ would have allowed government to sue social media giants and other 91Ƶbig faceless corporations91Ƶ for 91Ƶhurting people.91Ƶ

Government had modelled the law after legislation with which B.C. had sued tobacco companies, then later pharmaceutical companies.

But Laur pointed to legal experts, who have expressed skepticism about the ability to prove harm from social media.

91ƵThere are some predictable outcomes from that (consuming drugs), but measuring and quantifying harm from social media, that is way more difficult.91Ƶ

The agreement also speaks of government exploring 91Ƶopportunities for technology companies to help amplify official information for people in emergency situations like wildfires.91Ƶ

Meta, which blocks Canadian news from Facebook and Instagram because of the federal Online News Act, has also agreed to the 91Ƶdissemination of reputable information available from official sources, such as government agencies and emergency services91Ƶ in case of wildfires. That agreement includes what government calls 91Ƶadvertising support91Ƶ from Meta and the other companies to amplify 91Ƶawareness of safety resources91Ƶ throughout the wildfire season.

RELATED:

B.C. United91Ƶs Peter Milobar, MLA for Kamloops-North Thompson, an area that requently experiences wildfires, questioned that aspect of the agreement.

91ƵThis Premier, however, decided to sell out the local news industry to Facebook in a backroom deal in exchange for government advertising and a promise by Facebook to amplify NDP propaganda, conveniently in the months leading up to the provincial election,91Ƶ Milobar said.

That has real-world implications, because Meta91Ƶs on-going ban on local news continues to deny British Columbians, including current evacuees in the Fort Nelson area, access to local news posted via social media.

Eby has in the past complained about Meta91Ƶs block of local news and urged the company to re-consider.

Attorney-General Niki Sharma, meanwhile, defended the agreement against Milobar91Ƶs charges involving Facebook.

91ƵWe91Ƶre doing that for people that are facing really stressful wildfire situations,91Ƶ she said. 91ƵWhen they need information 91Ƶ the Premier has been clear on this 91Ƶ we expect those platforms to deliver that information straight from the ministry. We91Ƶre going to continue to do that work. We91Ƶre very proud of it.91Ƶ

Laur acknowledged problems with Meta91Ƶs role in amplifying government messages, when it blocks out local news.

91ƵYes, it does make it that the government is the sole messenger,91Ƶ Laur said. 91ƵThat91Ƶs the only story that goes through. If there (are) any competing challenges to the (government) messaging91Ƶthose contents and messages can91Ƶt be shared.91Ƶ

But Laur also tried to put things into perspective.

91ƵI do see that there is a challenge, but on a balance of probability in terms of mitigating harm, I think getting warnings out to people is more important, especially evacuation orders, than any disagreements about government messaging that there might be.91Ƶ

The online action table will meet again in the fall and government has said that it always has the option of re-tabling the legislation, assuming re-election.



Wolf Depner

About the Author: Wolf Depner

I joined the national team with Black Press Media in 2023 from the Peninsula News Review, where I had reported on Vancouver Island's Saanich Peninsula since 2019.
Read more



(or

91Ƶ

) document.head.appendChild(flippScript); window.flippxp = window.flippxp || {run: []}; window.flippxp.run.push(function() { window.flippxp.registerSlot("#flipp-ux-slot-ssdaw212", "Black Press Media Standard", 1281409, [312035]); }); }