As Mayor Tom Dyas noted at Monday91Ƶs (May 27) meeting, stalled construction at a downtown heritage site has become a 91Ƶbit of an eye-sore91Ƶ and is an emotional issue for council.
Plans by the Mark Anthony Group to build a 12-storey boutique hotel on the former site of the Daily Courier, at the corner of Lawrence Avenue and Water Street, were dashed after negotiations with a neighbouring property fell through.
91ƵWe had a verbal agreement with the neighbour and when it came time to sign that agreement it fell apart,91Ƶ Slava Korshunov, with Mark Anthony Group, told council. 91ƵWe were quite upset, we still want to build a hotel eventually.91Ƶ
READ MORE: Downtown Kelowna heritage facade could become 12-storey hotel
Previous to that was a plan for a wine education centre approved by the city in 2020 but scrapped after the group could not obtain a liquor license.
The lot has sat empty since with a crane on site and the heritage facade of the building supported by scaffolding. The current application is a four-storey mixed-use building.
91ƵWe are studying multiple options,91Ƶ Korshunov added. 91ƵIt needs to make financial sense for the company and it needs to make sense for the city.91Ƶ
Zoning limits the building to three storeys, so an amendment is required to allow four storeys. Councillor Charlie Hodge questioned staff about the proposed heights of the different applications.
91ƵOur primary concern is that equality development goes forward that incorporates the heritage facade there,91Ƶ Ryan Smith, director of planning and development said. 91ƵThere needs to be some flexibility to do that.91Ƶ
Hodge added there is a long history with previous councils to keep high-rises off that block.
91ƵCouncils came and went and it was fought over adamantly by many residents to keep it at that low block.91Ƶ
Coun. Luke Stack also preferred a lower-height building and preserving the character of the area.
91ƵIt91Ƶs not three storeys as Coun. Hodge would like it, but it91Ƶs close. If they do a good job of maintaining the heritage facade I think it91Ƶs a good way forward.91Ƶ
Coun. Rick Webber was concerned that the building91Ƶs use isn91Ƶt defined by the applicant.
91ƵWe91Ƶre being asked to approve it and send it along its way and I don91Ƶt know if that91Ƶs a good idea.91Ƶ
Coun. Ron Cannan suggested staff work with the applicant91Ƶs neighbour to see what could be accomplished.
91ƵSomething that could be a win-win for the community because this is a landmark building.91Ƶ
Smith told council staff have been pushing the applicant to move forward with the project.
91ƵI91Ƶm confident that whether it91Ƶs the four-storey or a higher option that something of great quality could happen.91Ƶ
Coun. Loyal Wooldridge, while supporting the development going to a public hearing, was frustrated that the project has stalled for four years and that the current application is lacking in detail.
91ƵMy expectation would be higher quality renderings to know exactly what the vision of this would be. It91Ƶs been in scaffold for far too long.91Ƶ
Council voted to give the height amendment first reading and send the project to a public hearing with Hodge opposed.
READ MORE: Kelowna city councillor confronts retirement